Online Resource Library
Commentary Index | Return to PrayerRequest.comAdam Clarke Commentary - Ezra 1:11 - 1:11
(Show All Books | Show All Chapters)
This Chapter Verse Commentaries:
All the vessels - were five thousand and four hundred - This place is without doubt corrupted; here it is said the sum of all the vessels, of every quality and kind, was five thousand four hundred; but the enumeration of the articles, as given in Ezr 1:9, Ezr 1:10, gives the sum of two thousand four hundred and ninety-nine only. But we can correct this account from 1 Esdras 2:13, 14.
I shall set both accounts down, that they may be compared together.
Ezr 1:9, Ezr 1:11 1 Esdras 2:13, 14
Golden chargers 30 Golden cups 1000
Silver chargers 1000 Silver cups 1000
Knives 29 Silver censers 29
Golden basons 30 Golden vials 30
Silver basons, second sort 410 Silver vials 2410
Other vessels 1000 Other vessels 1000
Said to be 5400 - only 2499 Total 5469
Difference of the first account from itself: 2901 Difference of the second account from the first: 69
According, therefore, to the sum total in Ezra, the sum total in Esdras is only 69 different. See the next chapter, Ezra 2 (note).
It may be said that the vessels did actually amount to 5400, and that the chief of them only were intended to be specified; and these happen to amount to 2499; but that it was not the design of Ezra to insert the whole; and that the ninth verse should be considered as stating, And of the chief of them, that is, the gold and silver articles, this is the number. But the expression in Ezr 1:10, other vessels, sets this conjecture aside: the place is most manifestly corrupted.