Online Resource Library
Commentary Index | Return to PrayerRequest.com | DownloadJames Hastings Dictionary of the NT: Breathing
Subjects in this Topic:
BREATHING.—On the evening of the Resurrection, the Lord appeared to the disciples, gave them the commission ‘As my Father, etc.,’ ‘and when he had said this, he breathed on them ( ἐíåöýóçóå ), and saith unto them, Receive ye the Holy Ghost ( ËÜâåôå Ðíåῦìá Ἅãéïí ). Whose soever sins … retained,’ Joh_20:21 f. The word ἐìöõóÜù is that employed by LXX Septuagint to translate ðִôç in Gen_2:7, Eze_37:9. As Westcott observes, ‘the same image which was used to describe the communication of the natural life [at the Creation] is here used to express the communication of the new, spiritual life of recreated humanity.’ The figure of human life depending on the breath of God is frequent in the Bible; besides above passages, see Job_12:10; Job_33:4, Psa_33:6, Isa_42:5, Dan_5:23, Act_17:25. In the following the breath of God is synonymous with the manifestation of His power: 2Sa_22:16, Job_37:10; Job_41:21, Isa_11:4. Both ideas seem to underlie our Lord’s action. The Church was now receiving its commission, and the efficacy and reality of the commission must depend upon the indwelling in the Church of the same Spirit as was in Christ Himself. ‘Alike the mission of the Church and its authority to forgive or retain sins are connected with a personal qualification, “Take ye the Holy Ghost” ’ (Edersheim, ii. 644). The work was not new, but was that already received from the Father by the Son and now handed on to that Church which was to be Christ’s body on earth. He had compared the action of the Spirit to breath (Joh_3:8). ‘By breathing on them He signified that the Holy Ghost was the Spirit not of the Father alone but likewise His own’ (Aug. St. John, translation 121).
Considerable difference of opinion exists as to whether the act of breathing, with the authority to retain or forgive sin, was bestowed upon the Apostles only or on others besides. Those who limit it to the Apostles urge that ‘disciples’ is always in the later chapters of St. John used to signify Apostles; and that, even if others were present, the analogy of Mat_28:16 and Mar_16:14-18 implies that the breathing and commission were limited to the Apostles. They would then see in the act a formal ministerial ordination.* [Note: Stanley (Christ. Inst. p. 192) states that ‘in the Abyssinian and Alexandrian Church ordination was, and still is, by breathing.’] On the other hand, Westcott and many others, comparing Luk_24:23, see no reason whatever for limiting the act and commission to Apostles. Even of the Eleven we know that Thomas at least was absent (Joh_20:24). The commission was one given to the Christian society as a body: in it in its corporate capacity would dwell the Holy Ghost, and the authority of retaining or forgiving sins.
Literature.—The Commentaries on St. John; Westcott, Revelation of Risen Lord, p. 81; Edersheim, Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah, ii. 644; Gore, Christian Ministry, p. 229; Stanley, Christian Institutions, p. 192.
J. B. Bristow.